How to Keep Your Cookies from Spreading

Temperature is so important in all aspects of the baking process, and not just as it relates to your oven temp. Keep an eye on these three things in particular if you notice that your cookies are spreading:

1. Butter consistency- Most recipes call for using “room temperature” butter, but that doesn’t mean you should leave your butter out on the counter for hours. Thirty minutes on the counter (less if your house is on the hot side) is more than enough. The goal is really just to be able to make an indent into the butter if you press on the stick with your finger. Very soft butter is one of the key culprits when cookies are spreading, so keep an eye on this one!

   
   

2. Hot pans? No thank you—If you are a home baker, chances are pretty good that you are baking batches of cookies back to back, using the same pans over and over. Whatever you do, make sure you let those pans cool down before placing new cookies on them, or that residual heat from your last batch can make your new cutouts start to soften and spread. Having at least 3-4 cookie sheets in rotation will help keep you from rushing to reuse a hot pan.

   
   
3. Chill that dough—If you absolutely love your recipe, but it tends to spread (and again, having done all the troubleshooting to see if you can figure out what’s causing it), pop your cookie sheets full of cutout cookies right into the fridge or freezer for a bit before baking. This should help your cookies retain their shapes through the baking process. That being said, if you’re anything like me, placing multiple cookie sheets in the fridge requires clearing out leftovers, arranging ketchup bottles for support, and keeping children from looking for snacks for a while. There are so many no-chill, no-spread cookie recipes out there, it may just be worth it to keep looking for one you can modify to suit your tastes.

What you’re baking ON is just as important a factor. Consider these two thoughts when making your next batch:

1. Do you have good quality pans?—I know it’s tempting to buy one of those inexpensive 3-packs of cookie sheets, but I promise, investing in good cookie sheets can make a huge difference in your results. They don’t have to be super expensive, but there are a couple of thing to look out for: light-colored pans are better than dark, and heavier pans are better than super-thin, lightweight, flexible ones.

   
   
2. Mesh mats for the win!—If you currently bake on bare pans, parchment, or silicone mats, try investing in a mesh baking mat, and you’ll suddenly find yourself singing “A Whole New World” when you see what a difference they make. Mesh mats have a silicone-coated open gridwork that not only leaves a super-professional consistent design on the back of your cookies, but the full airflow means that the cookies retain their shape much more than when baked on any other surface. 10/10, would bake again!

If you are currently experiencing cookie spread, take a look at the items on this list and see if any of them apply to you.  You never know—adjusting one thing in your process may make a world of difference in your end result! Good luck, and happy baking!